Skip to main content

The TAG Group

A founder studying a whiteboard mapping product, growth, people and funding with a checklist of HR, policies, compliance, culture and scaling, headlined 'First-time founders wait too long to hire their first HR leader.'

The pattern is almost universal.

The founder builds the company from three people to ten. Then ten to twenty-five. Then twenty-five to forty. Somewhere in that window, they hit a moment where every hire is a Slack referral, every offer is negotiated ad hoc, every performance issue is handled personally, and every culture question ends at their desk.

They tell themselves this is a temporary state. They tell themselves the People function is a nice-to-have they will invest in when the company is bigger. They tell themselves that hiring an HR leader too early is a luxury a scaling company cannot afford.

By the time they realize they were wrong, they have accumulated a set of costs that will take years to unwind.

Most founders think about the first HR hire as a cost. That framing is what leads to the delay. The right framing is that the first People leader is a risk mitigation investment.

The four costs founders do not see coming

First, the compensation drift. Every offer negotiated one at a time creates a compensation landscape that will not survive its first audit. By fifty employees, you have a set of pay decisions that were made in isolation and now sit next to each other, and the differences between them are impossible to defend. Fixing this after the fact costs six figures. Doing it right from hire twenty costs almost nothing.

Second, the manager tax. Managers who were promoted from individual contributor roles without any support are now making people decisions every day. Some of those decisions are quietly great. Some of them are quietly creating exposure. By the time the founder realizes this, they are not just hiring an HR leader. They are hiring an HR leader to clean up two years of manager decisions that should have been shaped by a real function from the start.

Third, the culture erosion. The vibe that carried the company through its first twenty hires does not scale. Somewhere between twenty and forty, the sixteenth hire walks in and does not automatically absorb the founder’s implicit expectations. Without a real People function shaping onboarding, values, and manager behavior, the culture drift is invisible for six months and then suddenly obvious to everyone. Reversing this after it takes hold is one of the hardest things a company ever does.

Fourth, the top-performer exit. The A players who joined early are watching all of this. They are watching how you handle the underperformer nobody wants to fire. They are watching how you promote. They are watching how you handle the offer that came in from a competitor. When they conclude the company is not being built with the discipline they expected, they leave. And they take institutional knowledge with them that the company will spend years trying to rebuild.

The math that changes the timing

Most founders think about the first HR hire as a cost. That framing is what leads to the delay. The right framing is that the first People leader is a risk mitigation investment. The exposure they prevent in year one alone typically exceeds their annual comp. The clarity they bring to the founder’s calendar creates capacity the founder can reinvest in the business. The manager development they lead compounds for years after.

The companies that get this right hire their first People leader between twenty and thirty-five employees. Not later. Somewhere in that window is where the founder starts to feel the strain of carrying every people decision themselves, and the company still has the discipline to bring in a leader who can shape the function before it calcifies.

What to look for when you are ready

Your first People leader is not an HR generalist. They are a founder-adjacent operator who can build the function from scratch. Someone who has seen this stage before. Someone who understands compensation, culture, manager development, and legal exposure as one integrated system, not four separate specialties. Someone who can push back on you as the founder without picking a fight, and who can build systems that outlast their tenure.

Hiring the wrong first People leader is worse than hiring one too late. But hiring the right one at the right moment is one of the highest-leverage decisions a founder ever makes. Most founders discover this two years after they should have.

Bukky Osifeso, founder of The TAG Group

Written by

Bukky Osifeso

Founder of The TAG Group. Bukky spent twenty years leading People strategy at Amgen, Disney and Netflix, and is the author of Rooted & Rising.